jQuery 1.4.4+ fails to load on pages with old Prototype (<= 1.5) or Current Prototype + Scriptaculous in IE

[SlexAxton]

This seems to be because old Prototypes would override the getelementsbyclassname native function, and inside of it, they'd use the $ sign.

In old versions of jQuery (1.4.2) our sizzle came before we set our global variables, now it comes after. That seems to break.

Examples

​http://jsfiddle.net/Bd7HU/7/ - jquery 1.4.4 and prototyp 1.5 fails ​http://jsfiddle.net/wMx9E/1/ - jquery 1.4.2 and prototype 1.5 ok ​http://jsfiddle.net/2zEj5/1/ - jquery 1.4.4 and prototype 1.6 ok

I'd say not to worry about this, but it's a really easy fix. Just move

  window.jQuery = window.$ = jQuery;

to the end of the file... I'll submit a patch.

[SlexAxton]

Hmmm, looks like the issue _does_ happen in recent versions of Prototype as well (in IEs only) if Scriptaclous is also on the page. (pretty common) (when prototype and scriptaculous come first).

​http://jsfiddle.net/dU7FB/3/

The same fix of moving the jQuery window leak to the bottom works. The build process is the only thing that makes this nontrivial.

We created $.noConflict to allow people to work with these other libraries, and since the fix here is just switching where code is executed, it seems like a good faith effort to make things easy for everyone.

[SlexAxton]

I submitted a patch that passes all tests for this here:

​https://github.com/jquery/jquery/pull/204

[john]

Landed.