tds[0] does not exist

[woakesd]

I get the following error warning in firebug using the lastest version in an application:

tds[0] is undefined

jQuery.support.reliableHiddenOffsets = tds[0].offsetHeight === 0;

I've tried to create a simple test case of this but failed.

[boushley]

We need more specifics on your environment. This line is line 160 in support.js and gets run as jQuery is loaded. So this is a bug that should appear by just including jQuery. More specifics or a test case would be necessary to determine specifically what is happening.

If we don't get anymore details, this is a worksforme.

[snover]

Please provide information about your environment (browser, OS, etc.) as well as the specific version of jQuery you are using and the scheme you are using (http, https, file, gopher, etc.).

[woakesd]

Hi, I will try to work out a test case for this, but in the meantime this was Firefox 3.6.12, Firebug 1.5.4, Windows Server 2008 r2 64 bit, jQuery is 1.4.4rc2 ( http://code.jquery.com/jquery-1.4.4rc2.js), jQueryUI 1.8.5.

However as noted that configuation by itself doesn't cause this.

The (intranet) site where this happens uses a frameset embedded in an iframe and most pages load jquery (including the page with the frameset.

However as I write this it has stopped happening.

Close the ticket I think, I dont really have time to isolate this and create a simple example.

[woakesd]

It's back!

But close anyway I can't think of a simple example for it.

I have found that removing jQuery from the frameset page within the iframe ensures this doesn't happen. I'll modify the code and live with it.

The errors appeared to happen when one of the pages within a frame loaded (and this page does have a function

jQuery(function() { xxx(); });

where xxx is a function that accesses the top page jQuery.

[snover]

Closing as per reporter request, and due to lack of a reproducible test case.

[anonymous]

Please re-open this ticket.

I'm experiencing this problem with the latest jQuery public release (1.4.3) using Firefox 3.6.12. The problem didn't manifest with jQuery 1.4.2. It does not happen under IE 8.0.7600.16385, Chrome 7.0.517.41 beta, or Safari 5.0.2 (7533.18.5). All my testing so far has been on a Windows 7 (32-bit) machine. The problem does seem related to framesets. In particular, there is a line in the jQuery code that attempts to set the innerHTML on a div but the innerHTML doesn't get changed. I will attempt to create a simple harness to illustrate the problem.

[kml]

Here's the HTML you can use to reproduce this bug:  http://jsfiddle.net/Ba4MR/. The version of Firefox I've seen this happen under is 3.6.12.

[kml]

Looking at the offending code, I suspected that wrapping the frameset element in a body element might provide a workaround; it appears to have worked. Nonetheless, it might still be worth addressing since surrounding the frameset with a body isn't strictly valid from the relevant XHTML spec.

[rwaldron]

I'm using FF 3.6.12 and am not experiencing the issue. I've tried both the fiddle and copying the whole case out and into its own file locally.

[kml]

Replying to rwaldron:

I'm using FF 3.6.12 and am not experiencing the issue. I've tried both the fiddle and copying the whole case out and into its own file locally.

I just copied out the fiddle, saved it into a new html file and opened it in FF 3.6.12. Inspecting the error console, I see the error occurs twice. Tomorrow I'll get some coworkers to try it out on their machines.

[rwaldron]

I'm not getting any errors. How about taking a screenshot?

[kml]

I've created a recording in MHT format but I can't figure out how to attach it to this ticket.

[rwaldron]

Zip it?

[kml]

It is zipped - I can't find any means of *attaching* it to this ticket. I'm not familiar with Trac. Does the ticket have to be in a particular state? Do I have to create a new ticket?

[rwaldron]

So... if you're using Firefox, can you just add this:  https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/1146/

Take a screenshot, upload it here:

 http://tinypic.com/

...OR...

 http://gyazo.com/en

either of those ways is easier.

[kml]

Here we go - I decided to use mongofiles. Thanks for the info. I guess direct file attachments aren't permitted in the ticket.  http://www.mongofiles.com/file/32413/bugrecording.zip

[rwaldron]

Something about this:

CommandLine="FIREFOX.EXE -REQUESTPENDING -OSINT -URL C:\USERS\KRISTIAN\DESKTOP\BUG.HTML"

tells me its not going to work on my linux machine. sorry dude, I tried to help. I still will if you wanna hook it up with a basic screen shot, otherwise, I cant help any further.

[kml]

Don't sweat it. Some coworkers are using Linux for dev - I'll see if they can reproduce it tomorrow. Hopefully I'll have something good to report. Thanks again.

[kml]

Don't sweat it. Some coworkers are using Linux for dev - I'll see if they can reproduce it tomorrow. Hopefully I'll have something good to report. Thanks again.

[anonymous]

I tried this using Firefox 3.6.11 on CentOS Linux and I also see the errors in my Firefox error console:

Error: tds[0] is undefined Source File:  http://code.jquery.com/jquery-1.4.3.js Line: 1053

[kml]

Here is a screenshot of the error console:  http://tinypic.com/r/2utgeom/7

[rwaldron]

This whole time, I was looking in Firebug.

[anonymous]

I can confirm this bug with my frame-based web application, too using Firefox 3.6.10.

jQuery 1.4.3 is simply included - no custom coding - and the JavaScript console throws the exact same error as previously described.

Switching back to 1.4.2 removes the error message so I suppose something in 1.4.3 is the cause of this.

[anonymous]

Me again, anonymous ;)

I've done some investigation on how jQuery is used in my project and I am automatically including it in most major files including frameset-only HTML files that do NOT have a BODY-tag.

This is most likely the cause !

[rwaldron]

#7469 is a duplicate of this ticket.

[dmethvin]

TL;DR: Error occurs with frameset documents that do not have a body. The code in support.js expects pages to have a body. In these cases the getElementsByTagName method returns undefined instead of a nodelist.

Moral of the story: jQuery wants a body.

[futureweb]

Same error here - Jquery 1.4.4 included within frameset file (XHTML 1.0 Frameset - without <body>) --> error:

Error: tds[0] is undefined Source: jquery-1.4.4.source.js Row: 1070

Any fix in sight?

[dmethvin]

Fix:  https://github.com/jquery/jquery/pull/144

I've attached a minimal repro case to the ticket, since it can't be done through jsfiddle.

[dmethvin]

XHMTL Frameset document test

[john]

Landed this pull request from Dave:  https://github.com/jquery/jquery/pull/199